What to Ask in Your Free Consultation with a Car Accident Lawyer
The days and weeks since your car accident have felt like a mad rush between therapy sessions, doctor appointments, and never-ending paperwork from the insurance company. It’s all you can do to deal with the pain in your neck, legs and back; the concussion they say you’ve suffered causes confusion and anxiety.
With your regular flow of income at a standstill, how will you ever cover the cost of all those treatments? Since the accident itself was not your fault, you expected help from your insurance company. Instead, it feels as if you’re getting the runaround. The tone of the emails and letters you have received is upsetting – they appear to imply that you’re exaggerating your issues in order to avoid going back to work. You’re being put under pressure to meet with medical experts for new testing. You’re being asked to sign forms you don’t understand.
After resisting the idea up until now, you’ve reached the point of needing legal advice. While you’ve never been the type of person who’s always threatening “I’ll sue!”, you need to speak with someone who knows what it all means and who can guide you through the paperwork and the process. There has to be an end in sight to this nightmare….
Where should you begin? What questions should you be asking when aking advantage of a lawyer’s offer of a free consultation? Beginning with the accident, everything has seemed to go wrong — you just have to get this meeting “right”. How will you know if this person is the “right” fit for your situation? How will you demonstrate that you are someone the lawyer would want as their client?
The Short Answer:
In your free consultation with a car accident lawyer, ask about their experience with cases like yours, how they handle accident benefits (SABS) and insurer exams (IME), who will work on your file, how updates work, and how fees and disbursements are paid. The right lawyer will explain your options clearly, without pressure to sue.
Preparing for your free consultation with a car accident lawyer (10-minute prep list):
Start by gathering the basic pieces of information. No need for a fancy binder or an index – just make sure to include:
- where you worked prior to the accident
- date and location of the accident
- your insurance information
- copy of the police report of the accident
- letters or emails you’ve received from the insurer
- list of your symptoms and how they affect your daily existence
Prepare to be believed.
While the insurance company does not appear to take your concerns and complaints, seriously, this consultation with a car accident lawyer is your chance to share your worries — about your health, about money, about what the future holds for you.
Prepare to be reassured
You have worried that hiring a car accident lawyer will make the insurance company punish you or stop paying you benefits. An experienced accident lawyer will be able to reassure you that your fear of retaliation is not founded in fact.
The consultation is a two-way street — prepare to get answers about:
- the injury lawyer’s experience:
- What percentage of your practice is focused on car accident work?
- Do you have experience with clients suffering from chronic pain, PTSD, and psychological (not just physical) injuries?
- What kinds of results have you achieved in cases like mine?
- Do most of your car accident cases settle, or do they go to trial?
- process, timeline, and who actually does the work:
- What are the next 3-5 steps if I decide to work with you?
- Who will be working on my file day to day? (Will it be the lawyer, an associate, or a law clerk?)
- How long do cases like mine usually take?
- communication and fit:
- How often will I hear from you?
- What is your preferred method of staying in touch – phone? email? video?
- How quickly may I expect you to respond to my calls or emails?
- fee structure and money matters (even if you hate asking – ask!)
- How does your contingency fee work? (What percentage of any settlement do you keep?)
- Who covers the cost for experts, records, and reports? (Are these recovered from the settlement?)
- Can you walk me through a sample settlement, showing what I would pay and what I’d receive?
- vision for the future:
- How do my symptoms fit with what you see in other clients?
- How might the accident and this case affect my ability to work and earn income over time?
Question to ask yourself after a consultation with an Ontario injury lawyer
Were there “red flag” signals (Uh-oh – this might not be the right one for me!) or were there “green flags” (Yes, this is the type of lawyer I need):
- Green flags –
- The lawyer’s explanations were clear, calm, and realistic.
- The lawyer was very direct about fees, timelines,, and about who would be handling your file.
- All your questions were answered.
- You were under no pressure to sign any agreements.
- There were no grandiose promises or guarantees of “winning big.”
- You felt “heard” and respected.
- You were not rushed through the appointment.
- The lawyer was interested in the symptoms you described which are not easily visible.
- Red flags –
- The lawyer used aggressive, fear-based language in referring to the insurance company.
- The lawyer was evasive about fees, timelines, or about who would be handling your file.
- You felt pressure to rush through the details and conclude the appointment.
- You felt pressure to hire the attorney and sign a contract immediately.
- You did not feel as if your questions had been answered fully.
How You Should Feel After a Free Consultation
Use this as your final gut-check:
☐ I feel believed
☐ I understand my options better than before
☐ I know what happens next
☐ I understand fees and costs more clearly
☐ I did not feel pressured to “sue” or decide on the spot
If those boxes aren’t mostly checked, it’s okay to speak to another lawyer.
FAQ: What to Ask in Your Free Consultation with a Car Accident Lawyer
-
Many are 15–30 minutes, sometimes longer depending on complexity.